Share this article:

Transgender students rights in school
March 23, 2017  

Supreme Court to Hear Transgender School Bathroom Rights Case in March

The U.S. Supreme Court announced that it will hear arguments in a major dispute on transgender rights on March 28, 2017. Gloucester County School Board v. GG (Case No. 16-273) is a case filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) on behalf of Gavin Grimm, a transgender male student at Gloucester High School in Virginia.

Gavin is challenging a school board policy that requires students to use the restrooms that match their “biological sex” (the gender they were assigned at birth), or to use one of a number of gender neutral bathrooms on campus. Gavin is arguing that the school’s bathroom policy, which segregates transgender students from their peers by requiring them to use “alternative, private” restroom facilities, is unconstitutional and also violates a federal law that prohibits sex discrimination by schools.

During his sophomore year, Gavin’s mother notified the Gloucester High School principal that Gavin was transitioning to a boy and requested permission for him to start using the boys’ restroom at school. The principal granted Gavin permission to do so and he used the boys’ bathroom for two months without issue. In the Fall of 2014, the school began to receive complaints from parents and residents of Gloucester County. In response, the school board adopted a policy which required students to use the restrooms that match their biological sex or to use the gender neutral bathrooms on campus.

Gavin filed a motion asking for the court to allow him to continue using the boys’ restroom for his junior year. The district court ruled against Gavin and found that federal law permitted schools to have separate restroom facilities for male and females based on “sex.” Therefore, by requiring Gavin to use the restroom consistent with his “sex,” which is female in the school district’s eye, the court found that the school district did not violate the law. Gavin appealed this decision.

On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals in the Fourth Circuit ruled in favor of Gavin by deferring to a U.S. Department of Education opinion letter from 2015, which stated that if schools separate students in restrooms on the basis of their sex, the school must treat transgender students consistent with their gender identity rather than their biological sex.

Following this decision, the United States Supreme Court voted to temporarily stay the Fourth Circuit’s ruling while it considered an appeal from the Gloucester County School Board. As such, Gavin continues to be barred from using the boys’ bathroom unless and until the Supreme Court rules in his favor.

Return to Students' Rights Blog


Call us with questions about our education law services or for a free initial consultation, fill out the form below. We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Is an IEP currently in place for your child?

215.540.2656 .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

400 Maryland Drive
Fort Washington, PA 19034